“St. RECIPE: 1. Fill rocks glass with ice. INGREDIENTS: 2oz St. Elmo Whiskey Bottle of cola 2 Luxardo Maraschino cherries. DON’T SEE YOUR FAVORITE RETAILER? Click here to send them information about St. Elmo Foods. We start with our very own Straight Bourbon Whiskey with Dark Cherry and Bourbon Vanilla Beans, then finish by mixing with cola. Add 2oz St. Elmo Whiskey. The only thing better than a flaming shrimp cocktail and 2-inch thick slab of prime rib at St. Elmo Steak House is one of the bar’s Elmo Colas. The legendary St. Elmo Steak House has been an Indianapolis institution for more than a century and is regularly listed among the best steak houses in the country. Fill glass with cola But a rather simple cocktail has given the iconic restaurant a new claim to fame. 2. World Famous St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce™ St. Elmo Seasoning Izzy's Sauce The signature St. Elmo Steak House cocktail, the Elmo Cola, now in a can. “A ready-to-drink Elmo Cola cocktail takes this convenience to a whole new level. It offers a refreshing balance of crisp cola and smooth bourbon. Elmo Steak House’s retail program was born from the concept of getting our signature items and flavors into people’s homes,” said Craig Huse, president of Huse Culinary. 3.